Purple Pinecones
The Second String Debate Team
Friday, January 20, 2023
Purple Pinecones
Tuesday, January 17, 2023
The Big SAD
The Big SAD
By: Javan Bair
That bastard Benjamin Franklin robs us of our precious sunlight once a year, every year. I actually have no idea if Benjamin Franklin invented daylight savings, I learned that from the movie National Treasure like fifteen years ago. But Nicholas Cage is a reliable source. Right? Whether or not Benjamin Franklin did take a break from being one of the Founding Fathers of the United States, being a diplomat, posing for his portrait on the one-hundred dollar bill, and flying kites in lightning storms to develop daylight savings is beside the point. Because that time has come once again. And I speak for exclusively for myself, but I absolutely dread this time of year. I always encounter this overwhelming feeling of persistent sadness.
For most of my life, I thought this was an uncommon feeling. But then I learned about the big SAD. Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD), also known as Seasonal Depression. And there is a slew of reasons that the real spooky season begins right after Halloween for most people.
According to the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), “Millions of American adults may suffer from SAD, although many may not know they have the condition.” According to the research completed by NIMH, reasons for experiencing these seasonal symptoms may include: a lack of sunlight, a correlated lack of vitamin-D, isolation due to weather, and the exacerbation of pre-existing mental health conditions. And that last one is a straight up fucking B-I-N-G-O for me.
My anxieties run rampant during this time of year.
In an effort to be as honest and transparent as possible, I'll admit that during this time of year my anxiety manifests in persistent feelings of loss (past and potential) and worthlessness. I always tend to over analyze my current position in life. Which is also not uncommon. We all feel like burnouts sometimes. We all feel lost. We all feel displaced. We all feel as though our progress is simply not enough. And I find this to be so bizarre. After all, this a common on trope in everyone’s human experience. But the other commonality we all share is a trouble in expressing these thoughts of inadequacy, hopelessness, and uncertainty. It’s really fucking hard to open up.
That’s why I do this. My brain is much better connected to my hands than it is to my mouth. I can express my thoughts and emotions on paper so much better than I can when I try to use the old face hole. But there is profound impact in sharing your thoughts out loud. I implore anyone experiencing depression, seasonal or otherwise, to talk to someone. Preferably a professional. But there’s also no harm in commiserating with the homies. Start local. Be open with your friends. You may find that your struggle is not so singular.
But here I am, face to face with all my seasonal demons once again. And they are really trying to fuck with me this year. So, I am going to lean into the emotions they invoke. Before I go further, I am not proposing this as a method of coping or healing for anyone else. But, I have spent at least the last decades worth of winters doing all I can to escape the way I feel. But now I want to feel every last fucking bit of what I am afraid of. I am embracing the kind of pain that sits in the gut pocket of our soul and strips us of the very air we need to breath. I want to learn from this pain rather than continually trying to silence it. I find myself beginning to surrender to the consequences of the decisions I have made and others have made around me. I am also diving deeper into the feelings of happiness that make that same part of my soul swell with excitement. I am finding that it is this duality that makes our consciousness worth possessing.
As far as the feelings of being lost or not being where I should be in life, I’ll be taking a mantra from my friend Carlin. The other day we were talking and I shared with him the way I have been feeling. He not only shared the same experience, but he also told me something that will resonate with me for a long time. “This is it… For right now.” Understand where you are. Appreciate where you are. And continue to grow from this position.
We all have a tendency to become downtrodden during this time of year. But I hope that this short piece can serve as a reminder that none of us our alone. If you read this and it resonated with you, let’s talk about in the comments.
The big SAD is here. We can all band together and blame Benjamin Franklin based off of one obscure scene from a dated Disney movie or we can act as a support system for another through the cold and dreary foreseeable future. I prefer the latter.
P.S.
Here's an article about Benjamin Franklin’s involvement in day light savings:
https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nc/charlotte/weather/2021/02/24/why-daylight-saving-time-
Here's the article I sourced from the National Institute of Mental Health. It has a lot of great information beyond what I used it for:
https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/seasonal-affective-disorder
Sunday, January 15, 2023
The Billy Madison Experience
By:
Javan Bair
When I decided to use my
GI Bill benefits and go to college instead of reenlisting for another four
years, my Army leadership was kind and reassuring. They were kind enough to remind
me that at twenty-six years old, I was eight years, nearly an entire decade more
senior than the average college freshman. And they reassured me that due to my age
and military background, I would likely fail college. There was no way I could
assimilate into the fabled landscape of higher education—one comprised of
progressive ideologies and kindness. I was too old of a dog to learn new
tricks. Who did I think I was? Billy Madison?
Billy
Madison is a reference to the classic Adam Sandler film. Madison, a grown man,
must complete grades K 12 as he navigates various age gaps and complexities he
encounters along the way.
I was
out of touch with my classmates during my first two years at CU Denver. Our age
difference was evident in appearance and behavior. But as I progressed through
my program and reached my 3000-4000 level courses, I began to feel more
comfortable. Not only were the classes more stimulating, and the students were
a little closer to my age, but I had allowed myself to become fully immersed in
the experience of being a student. I realized that everyone on campus, despite
their age or prior experience, is here to gain an education.
The significant
part about having a Billy Madison-inspired student veteran experience at CU
Denver is that I was not alone. The CU Denver campus is commuter based, meaning
that veterans who settled anywhere near the Denver area can attend due to the
flexible nature of the class schedules. I have met a decent number of veterans on
campus that are succeeding in college because they have also embraced this new
chapter in their lives.
Carlin Page, a junior at
CU Denver, explained his post-military college experience and outlook on this
new portion of his life. “Growing up, going to school was a chore. But coming
back to school as a non-traditional student, I have a different outlook. I
think of everything I can accomplish if I pay attention for a couple of hours a
day. Knowledge is freedom.”
So, if you are a student
veteran, nervous about succeeding in college, you can either take to heart the
kind and reassuring sentiments that your leadership gave to you on your way out
or can go back to school, back to school and prove to Uncle Sam that you are
not a fool. With enough effort, you can become the Miles Davis of undergraduate
programs if you choose.
And if my Billy Madison references are coming
across as a bit dated, that’s probably because I’m nearly an entire decade
older than the average college student.
Thursday, January 12, 2023
The Zeitgeist Diaries Pt. 2 - Redundancy
By: Javan Bair
It wouldn’t be a used truck
dealership if there weren’t a steel sign with the company logo in front of the
office. In big, brushed metal letters fixed inside of a banner, the company name
TTI Trucks is the very first thing you see when you walk inside.
Like most companies, we place our
logo anywhere and everywhere we possibly can. The logo is everywhere you look. Our
hats, t-shirts, license plates, trucks, and coffee cups. Everything has a logo
on it. For Christ’s sake, I can’t tell you how many times I have been cut off
by a truck with TTI mudflaps on my way to work.
So after about a month of working
there and seeing this logo on every square foot of my workspace, I realized
something. I have no clue what the “TTI” in “TTI Trucks” stands for. I ask Mike
what it means, and he tells me he has no clue. He has worked here for five
years, and that strikes me as odd. So, I ask around, and no one seems to know.
Until I asked Angie, the girl who did our payroll, for a document with our
entire company name printed.
And there it was. In all of its repetitive
glory, “Turner Trucks Incorporated Trucks.” “Wow. The word “trucks” is in our
company name twice. Let there be no confusion that we sell trucks and truck
parts. The redundancy makes it undoubtedly funny. (Redundancy: the inclusion of
extra components which are not strictly necessary to functioning in case of
failure in other components.) The overuse of the word trucks in the company is accurately
redundant as it neither aids nor diminishes anything from a money-making standpoint.
But it did make for a name that rolls off the tongue nicely. Nicely enough for
me to begin answering the phone at the parts desk like “Turner Trucks
Incorporated Trucks. This is Trucks. How can I help you find Trucks?”
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We even had cloth masks made with
our secretly redundant logos on them. I’m not sure why we had those made. We wore them one time.
Quite literally one time that I can remember. And you would have thought that
some of my coworkers were channeling the spirit of Rosa Parks, the way they
were fiercely preaching about overcoming oppression and the need for more civil
liberties and rights. But unlike Rosa Parks, who was fighting for freedom while
living through the brutal realities of racism and forced segregation. These
were grown-ass, blue-collar men falling to pieces behind a small piece of cloth.
I am not saying there is no
validity to the argument over the infringement of masks on the principles of
freedom. But at the time, placing the fabric on our mouths to potentially stop
old people from dying seemed quite minimal compared to the state of other things
in America. We had the two oldest and least qualified potential candidates
vying for the most important job in the world during a key moment in our nation’s
history. The streets of most major cities were still riddled with palpable
tensions between citizens and police officers. Protests were erupting
everywhere, all the time, and about anything. Violent crime had risen significantly
since the pandemic began. Drug overdoses were skyrocketing. The masks just seemed
a bit redundant in comparison. And despite everything that happened, the “goddamn,
pussy, libtard, queer masks” remained a central point of contention.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If I had to give an estimate, I
would say that Gus weighed approximately seven-thousand pounds. He was a morbidly
obese cokehead, which I thought was impossible before meeting him. He was a
co-worker of mine during this period. He sold used parts at the counter next to
Mike. And this dude got COVID so fucking bad that it nearly killed him. He miraculously
pulled through and survived. He will be on oxygen for the rest of his life, but
that’s incredible considering a virus that targets the cardiovascular system specifically
was thwarted by a heart filled to the brim with cholesterol from numerous years
of deep-fried tamales and eight balls. Oh, and all the doctors and medicine,
which he thinks are liberal propaganda.
He was a full-blown disciple of Qanon,
Breitbart, Infowars, and any other conspiracy-driven narrative. He was, therefore,
not allowed to admit that COVID was real even after it put him in the hospital
for a complete month. He took one round of the vaccine and then read an article
that Bill Gates was using it to put microchips inside of people and just never
went back for a second dose. We would argue incessantly about politics and COVID
over the soft whispering sound from his oxygen tank as it released pressure.
That little *psst* sound would serve as a constant reminder that he really did
have COVID and it could potentially be life-threatening to high-risk (the old
and severely out of shape). If I ever brought this up to him, I was given the
same response. “Fuck you” *psst* “You stupid ass” *psst* “Democrat!” *psst* It
was like arguing with a walkie-talkie. He would then angrily grab his little oxygen
tank and waddle away until I could no longer hear the faint sound of me winning
another argument. *psst*
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
All at once, in a large sweeping fashion.
Everyone and their grandmothers got COVID at TTI. After Gus, the dominos just continued
to fall. Somehow, during my part-time hours spent at work, I never contracted
COVID.
It was just me and another guy, Thomas,
who didn’t get COVID. I assume the variants that I was exposed to only affected
full-time employees, and Thomas did not get it because he works alone in the far
corner of our lot in the back of an old FED Ex truck. But that is a whole
different story for a whole different time.
For weeks I would come into work,
and there would be three people out of the usual thirty working there. But business
did not slow down. Not for one second. I have never been so happy to be a
part-time employee anywhere in my life. There would be a sea of angry customers
wondering where their truck parts were, and I would just look at the clock and realize,
“Oh, look at that! Time for class!” And I would leave and go to school, where I
would wear one of the custom cloth TTI masks and spend the rest of my afternoon
on what felt like the other side of the planet.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I stand by my defense of college.
It is not (usually) a socialist brainwashing seminar like Fox News and The
Daily Wire would like you to believe. In fact, all those anchors and reporters
that consistently shit on institutions of higher education all went to one.
They wouldn’t have their jobs if they didn’t. When Ben Shapiro drones on about
the alleged brainwashing occurring at colleges across the nation, never forget that
he himself is a graduate of Harvard and UCLA. However, there are times that colleges
live up to the types of stereotypes that give reporters like Tucker Carlson wet
dreams. This was never more evident than when classes were reopened in the fall
of 2020.
CU reopened its doors with a no
negotiation, one-hundred percent mask mandate, and a very limited number of
in-person courses.
The mandate itself was little to no
issue to me. Much like the escape from the mundane nature of the pandemic that
I was receiving by working at TTI, the school re-opening served as a similar
reminder of regular life. So, if all I had to do was wear a mask to attend
classes, then so be it.
But Jesus H Christ did these young
students who had never had any taste of power and got totally shitfaced on the
role of enforcing the mandates on others who did not comply. And, of course
they did. Most of these young people were consuming media that reinforced the
idea that those unwilling to comply with mask mandates were synonymous with the
mob of Qanon dipshits trying to rip down 5G towers. While it is true that those
people do often stay in the same camp, they don’t usually share the same tent.
These misguided liberal children of conservative parents thought they were
playing an important role in saving humanity while pissing their Dads off. It
was a perfect situation for misguided post-teenage angst. Unfortunately for
them, they were just as annoying and as pedantic as the anti-maskers screaming
about their religious and constitutional rights to abstain from masks. As they
attempted to mock and berate their right-wing opponents, they became the very cannon
fodder needed to fill the b roll footage spots on Fox News. The pro-mask
policing student bodies on campuses all over the nation were just as terrible
as the deranged alt-right religious fanatic shouting at members of their town hall
representatives about their local mask mandates. “You cannot force me to cover
my mouth. God intended our mouths to be free from sinful oppression. God gave
me this hole to breathe from. God gave me this hole, and you cannot control it!
That’s God’s Hole!” That’s not a direct
quote, but we’ve all seen the videos at this point, and I'm not that far off.
Admittedly though, the return to in-person
classes felt somber. Most of the campus was closed, aside from a couple of
different buildings. Sure we had human contact in the realm of education once
more, but this felt like human contact Lite. Sure, being around the presence of
enough masked faces could make you feel alive again, but it’s just not the same
as the full-strength stuff. No one spoke to anyone else in the halls or classrooms.
It was just bleak. Everything felt gray. If it weren’t for the complete and
total abandonment of the mask mandates at TTI, I probably would have been
begging strangers to cough into my open mouth so I could feel alive again.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
“The masks are an
infringement on my fucking rights!” I was often yelled at by coworkers that looked
like deer in the headlights if you mentioned the Patriot Act.
“The masks are not a fucking option!
If you don’t comply, you are murdering people!” I would often hear similar
sentiments being screamed by students who were ironically obsessed with preserving our democracy.
The argument about masks has never
been over freedom v. oppression. It has always been about ability v.
regulation. And that is the real degree of freedom that we have in this country.
We do not, nor have we ever lived in a place with true freedom or unlimited liberties.
In America, you have the ability to do what you want until it no longer adheres
to an existing regulation. No matter where your allegiance was sworn at this
time, you were still not allowed to enter a restaurant and eat food without a
mask on. Stop pretending that you are somehow living in a free country. That is
a fever dream. We live and operate according to the freedoms allocated to us.
And if I have to wear a mask to go
to a brewery and sit inside like a civilized human instead of sitting at a
picnic table in the middle of a closed-down street in December like some kind
of side character in Grand Theft Auto, then so be it.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Much like the name Turner Trucks Inc.
Trucks, there is a comically valuable level of redundancy in the arguments
presented in this piece. The battle that was waged between the hardcore pro and
anti-maskers was relevant in terms of their place in time but absolutely
fucking useless in terms of assisting our country as it navigated a pandemic. These
two groups of people made a massively absurd amount of noise, but they achieved
nothing. They were extra components unnecessary to the functionality of our
nation. These folks were merely cheerleaders for ideals that were not even their
own.
And at the end of it, both
approaches appeared useless. Shortly after everyone at TTI contracted COVID, CU
Denver canceled all classes for the next semester and a half because many of our masked student population had also
gotten COVID. Looking back, is it fair to admit we had no fucking idea how to resolve
the pandemic? It seems that we were simply adding more and more redundant parts to the machine rather
than addressing the central cause of all of our problems, an already broken two-party
system.
***Pt. 3 Coming Next Week***
Thursday, January 5, 2023
The Zeitgeist Diaries Pt. 1
By: Javan Bair
Somehow, I had managed to feel even
more trapped in the day to day grind than I did before the pandemic began. The
two major time consumers in my life, work and school had become constant
fixtures in my home. MY desk loomed in my bedroom as if to remind me that even
in the imminent fall of the world, I was still merely a cog in a profit-driven
machine.
A significant number of people
loved working from home during the pandemic. Many of them are still doing it to
this day. At first, I have to admit that I loved working from home. It was a
dream come true to hang out in sweatpants and smoke weed with my dog while
pretending my job still had meaning.
But countless hours spent stoned
and alone had finally lost their luster, and I decided I needed some kind of
alteration in my life’s direction.
I switched all my classes to CU
Denver and moved in with a couple of friends that needed a roommate. They had
an apartment that was “basically in Denver.” And for the price in rent, I
couldn’t believe how affordable this apartment was in the notoriously expensive
and saturated Denver market.
I quickly found out that I was not
“basically in Denver. I was in Thornton, which is fine if you are searching for
an alternative to everything that makes Denver, Denver. Where Denver is
contemporary and creative, Thornton is suburban and purposefully ordinary. The
only thing both areas have in common is an absurd number of homeless people.
Classes were supposed to resume in
person a couple of days after I moved up there. But COVID had other plans, and
classes were once again relegated to zoom meetings and Microsoft office meeting
rooms. I was trapped again. The world had briefly reopened, and then the omicron
variant came in like Dikembe Mutombo and swatted all our hopes and dream of
normalcy into the trashcan. And taking the 20-minute drive from Thornton to
downtown was to no avail. Aside from the occasional protest, Denver had very
little excitement at the time. Everything was either closed, or you sat outside
on picnic tables outside of a microbrewery and drank beer in the frigid cold. I
was drinking at one of these urban winter survival courses once and made direct
eye contact with a homeless person doing the same thing I was. Except, he was
doing it for far less money. The pandemic was nonsensical, monotonous, and downright
arduous unless you were homeless. The pandemic was like a never-ending summer
camp for them.
Because I hadn’t yet given up on myself enough to forgo my worldly possessions and join the Forever Camp on Colfax Ave. And I couldn’t afford to move out of Thornton, so I was forced to resume our regularly scheduled programming. I was back to smoking weed, hanging out with the dog, doing homework, and working in the form of sending meaningless emails to coworkers day in and day out. New location. Same directionless feeling.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My roommate Mike still worked a regular
job. He got up at 7:00 every morning and came home at 6:00, a ritual beginning to
feel foreign to me. Sure, he still came home with the glaze of the workingman’s
dread over his eyes. He would openly vocalize how much he hates work and his co-workers.
But I was jealous of him. He was leaving the house every day and somewhat
living with some sense of normalcy.
He worked as the manager of a medium-duty
truck salvage yard/dealership in Denver called TTI Trucks. If the term “medium-duty
truck salvage yard and dealership” sounds sketchy, that’s because it is. The essential
business model of TTI Trucks is to purchase used box trucks at auction and
either sell them back to the general public if they run or strip them for parts
that they sell back to the general public if they don’t run. It’s kind of like
recycling, except more dangerous. These aren’t plastic bags being turned into
flimsier bags; these are parts for the big trucks on the highway that you pass
on your way to work. Very sketchy.
So, I was all in when he offered me
a part-time job. I grew up in salvage yards. My dad kept our family cars
running with parts from U-Pull-And-Pay for most of my life. As a toddler, I
used to sit in dilapidated vehicles that had already been ransacked by others
while my Dad would pull the parts he needed. Those are some of my fondest
memories, sincerely. In addition, my Dad has been a mechanic his whole life,
and as a result, I grew up around shops like TTI.
Mike knew this about me, and that’s
why he thought I might enjoy working part-time at TTI while I was still in college.
In addition, TTI needed help. Unlike most industries in the time of COVID, the
trucking industry hit a major boom. The rise of online shopping binges that
kept many people tethered to reality during the pandemic caused a subsequent surge
in the need to deliver those products. The demand for delivery drivers and
transport services went through the roof, and trucks worldwide began clocking
in more miles than ever before. But more miles equals more wear, and more wear
equals broken and worn-out parts that must be replaced.
Truck drivers are losing money when
their trucks are not operating correctly. And just like every other good or
service during the pandemic, truck parts were no different. They we limited and
challenging to come across. Acquiring new parts in a timely manner became an
act of God. And thus, TTI Trucks arose as the prodigal son of the Western Front
trucking industry.
The parts were sold faster than the
trucks could be purchased, and TTI needed more help pulling and selling the
parts. The manual labor force in this country does not slow down for politics
or pandemics. Even in times of chaos, one thing remains true in the United
States, wrenches must be turned, and those doing so must be paid. The pandemic
was good for TTI and those that worked there.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
“This job is ghetto as hell.” I think
to myself as I use one of our jump boxes to try and start a truck that was
literally recovered from a highway fire. The jump box I use is a steel
furniture dolly with car batteries stacked on top of one another. They are inconveniently
heavy and very unsafe. I hook cables to the battery terminal and let this old International
4700 rip. The engine remarkably starts,
but the rest of the truck appears unsalvageable. I take pictures of the truck,
a video to prove that it does, in fact, run despite looking like it was used on
the set of a Michael Bay film, and see what parts are still salvageable and
advertise those parts online. It is a very blue-collar job. It’s dirty. My co-workers
are dirty. Everything smells like grease, diesel, cigarettes, farts, and Copenhagen.
And on a somewhat hereditary level, I like it.
After a couple of months at this
job, the world began to open, and some of my classes began occurring in real
classrooms again. I began to split my time 50/50 between CU Denver and TTI Trucks.
A College of Liberal Arts and a blue-collar mechanic shop and salvage yard. I
believe there to be no two more polar opposite locations in the universe. They
are the antithesis of one another.
At CU Denver, the world is viewed through
a lens that portrays a myriad of left-leaning agendas common throughout academia.
Despite how the media represents the college, it is not just a crash course in communism
nor an indoctrination to Antifa. But the tropes and stereotypes do exist. Anti-fascist
poetry club posters and Joe Rogan petitions decorate the hallways. At TTI
Trucks, the agenda is all over the spectrum of right-wing beliefs, everything from
the overtly Christian Conservatives to the heartfelt followers of Qanon. There
is no shortage of unfounded conspiratorial beliefs to be heard.
I existed in both of these places
during a time of intense division in this country. I was bounced around between
major ideologies like a pinball during COVID, the protests, the election, the vaccine
rollout, the mask mandates, and every other piece of duplicitous chaos that
unfolded between 2020 and 2022.
I learned, worked, and lived among
the two groups in this country that seem to have the most disdain for one
another but spend almost no time commingling.
I found myself smack dab in the middle
of the American Zeitgeist (definition: the defining spirit or mood of a
particular period of history as shown by the ideas and beliefs of the time).
This isn’t some “take a walk in
someone else’s shoes” story or some profound tale of self-discovery and
unification in a time of division. Those would both be excellent options, but I
fear we have long since departed from being able to digest anything from a
central point of view in this country. Instead, I will tell you stories about
the last two wild fucking years I have spent among these two vastly different groups,
and hopefully, by the end of it, you realize just how ass-backward we have become
as a nation. What you choose to do with that information is entirely up to you.
***Part 2 is coming next week***
Wednesday, July 13, 2022
Duck Creek Shit Storm
Karli and I pulled up to Duck Creek and drove through what
seemed to be a pretty average “car camping” site. There were small, treed areas
separated by thirty or so meters scattered among both sides of the road that
were already about half full of various RV’s and pickups. Based on the
recommendation of our friends who had camped here prior, we kept pushing
through the valley of the weekenders. After about a mile, we hooked a turn and
we were in one of the most stunning landscapes I have ever seen.
This valley looked like something out of a painting. We had
finally achieved our much needed vacation from the city of Denver.
We drove down the road for what felt like hours, just taking
in all this mountain range had to offer. We said very little on this portion of
the drive because the scenery was simply awe inspiring. We finally found a
perfect little secluded spot, miles and miles down the road.
This was it. I parked the car. We let the dogs out and we
set up camp. This felt perfect. The woman I love. Our dogs, Sturgill and Hank.
Cold beer. Food cooked over a fire. I felt like I was living out a country song.
Hell, I felt like Zac Brown was just whispering sweet, soft little nothings
into my ear as I rode on the shoulders of Garth Brooks. Yeah, it was that kind
of trip.
For two days and one night, this was absolute paradise. The
second night was… uh, more chaotic.
Camping out of the back of a Subaru Crosstrek with two grown
ass people, and two medium dogs is very tight but doable. We had the backseats
folded down and had fit a decent sized air mattress in the back. The dogs were
supposed to sleep at our feet, but they basically just did whatever they fucking
wanted to because they are dogs that were being forced to sleep in a car. The
first night went ok. A little uncomfortable, but we figured it was manageable.
The second night came, we piled into the back of the car,
and we all fell asleep. I was asleep for three and a half seconds before the
dogs started stomping me out like I was being initiated into a fucking gang. I
finally got them to settle and laid my head down once more. Insert the most
jarring panting noises I have ever heard. They were panting so hard, they were
shaking the car. I could not sleep and I was getting very upset. I let the dogs
outside, hoping they just needed to pee or poop. I was partially right. They
both peed and got back in the car. I fell back asleep.
I woke to even worse panting, a really strange noise, and
utter darkness. I thought it came from outside. “Oh, fuck! Is that moose we saw
yesterday out there?” I asked myself. I groggily came to, and my head began to
fill with questions, “Was there an animal outside? Is that why the boys were
acting so crazy and denying me of my precious sleep? What time is it?” All of
these questions were cut short by the intrusion of a smell. “Is that a fart?” I
think to myself. And then it hits me. That was the sound I heard. And that was
no fart… that was a shart.
“That’s shit! That’s fucking shit!” I start to repeat with
increasing levels of volume every time I say it. Karli wakes up as I am chanting,
“That’s shit. That’s fucking shit.” As she begins to put the confusing pieces
of me yelling and trying to get the dogs out of the car together, she begins to
ask me what in the hell I’m talking about. “Sturgill shit somewhere in the
car!” As the dome lights in the car finally turn on, I realize that the
“somewhere” that Sturgill shit was, in fact, right next to my head.
At this point, I get Hank out of the car and Sturgill
quickly follows. Sturgill is a long, tall dog that resembles much more of a
horse than a K9. As his body sneaks past me, he manages to brush my face with
his exceptionally long tail. Normally, this would be of no issue. But due to
the explosive diarrhea that he had just expelled from his bowels and onto our
bed, this was a huge problem.
My tone now shifts from that of confusion and frustration,
to unfiltered rage and fury “There is shit on my face! There is shit on my
goddamn face!” I begin another chant, as if stating my misfortunes will somehow
resolve them. I scramble out of the car still screaming about the smear of dog
poo on my face. Not a ton of shit, mind you. But any amount on your face is
warrant for an emotional reaction. I am so upset that I scare Hank and he just
runs away. I don’t blame him, that’s the correct response when you are a
thirty-eight pound labradoodle who doesn’t understand English but are smart
enough to understand that your brother just shit on your Dad’s face and Dad is
now throwing poop covered items out of the car while informing your brother
that he will spend the rest of his days in these woods. It is also worth noting,
I looked criminally insane during this portion. The smell was so awful that I
was gagging, dry heaving, and still yelling obscenities at my dog. All the
while, Karli is laughing hysterically, and I don’t blame her. That’s the
correct response when you are a nurse and shit is a normality. When you look
over and your boyfriend is behaving as though he just contracted Ebola and
smoked meth simultaneously, you laugh.
Hank finally returns and we load up everything into our 2021
toilet on wheels and begin our drive home… with the windows down, of course.
Karli had to drive at first because there was so much stuff
jammed into the back of the vehicle that I couldn’t fit in the drivers seat. We
got on the narrow, two-lane, mountain highway in the middle of the night and two
semi-trucks and trailers zoomed past us and shook the Crosstrek violently. You
know, like a small car with all of its windows down would shake when being
passed at an opposing seventy-five miles per hour. “Nope. You have to drive.”
Karli says to me.
We pull over to the side of the highway and rearrange the
car, again. I’m nearing the end of my patience with this escapade and I am just
fucking ready to be home.
I’m driving down the highway, the steering wheel is only
inches from my chest, all the windows were down, and to say I was upset would
be a gross understatement. I looked at my dog and once again told him I should
have left him in the woods. I obviously did not mean this. Sturgill is my horse
dog, my sweet boy, my dog. But in this moment, I was being downright mean to
him. Karli informed me that saying horrible things like that was not funny. I
wasn’t trying to be funny. I was trying to be hurtful because I was angry.
There was, after all, dog shit on my face. But as we hurdled down the road
surrounded only by the sounds of the headwind of the highway that drowned out
the already low sound of the radio, my mind began to wander. The cold air that
was bellowing through the open car windows was the only thing keeping me awake.
Well, that and the overpowering stench of dog shit that smelled strangely
reminiscent of Cheerios. The smell was so pungent I couldn’t keep my mind off
of Sturgill.
I began to feel lower than low. As I should have. I said
some off the wall shit to him when I was angry. It’s times like those where I
really hope our dogs can’t understand us. But even if he couldn’t verbally express
anything to me, his face spoke volumes. I could tell that he was hurt. He was
afraid and uncomfortable because he knew that his Dad was furious with him. I
looked at that sad face of his and I thought of that same boyish face that
would light up when I came home. That same face that would look up at me with
complete and total trust. That same, sweet face that kept me company throughout
pandemic lockdowns and some of the hardest chapters of my life. I was flooded
with all of the countless joys that dog has brought to my life.
I look back at him and I earnestly apologized. He seemed to
accept my gesture.
We continued down the road as the wind blasted us and the
dogs. Karli looks at me and smiles, as if to remind me that everything is going
to be ok, and that we will laugh about this someday. I smile in return because
I know she is right. I look in the rear view mirror and I see Hank, just
sitting there looking justifiably confused and cold. I look for Sturgill and I
notice that he is squatting and is facing the rear window. He is once again,
shitting the car. I take a deep breath in to process the situation. In
retrospect, that was poorly timed inhale. I look over at Karli and simply say
“He’s pooping again.” “Oh, wow. That’s really unfortunate.” She responds. We
both focus back on the road and realize there is nothing we can do about any of
this right now. It was relieving. We both just dug into our reality and
realized that we had a unfortunately pungent drive ahead of us, but we were
going to make it.
Sometimes life is an oasis in the mountains. Sometimes life
is a Subaru filled with watery dog shit. It is the reaction to either scenario
that dictates the overall energy of your life.
Strive to move with grace and eloquence through all aspects
of life and reciprocate love to those who give theirs to you. Even if they shit
on your face.
Dedicated to my
little family:
Karli, Hank, and
Sturgill aka “The New Amber Turd”
Monday, June 20, 2022
Anatomy of A Reality
Buried
deep in the vast and uncompromising woods of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan is
the story of one of America’s most unique murder trials. The relatively quiet
and calm landscape of the Upper Peninsula, more commonly referred to by its
residences as the “UP” was the stage for a story that would prove to be
monumental in terms of its real life decision and its Hollywood depiction.
The
film noir classic Anatomy of A Murder is a legendary piece of American
cinema and has cemented itself in the canon of outstanding courtroom dramas for
good reason. Since the film’s release in 1959, it has continually captivated
audiences for decades. The movie weaves the tale of one man’s perceived
justification for committing first degree murder and his attorney’s struggle to
convince a jury to find merit in that argument. The film tackles the
dichotomous situation presented by one man’s crime of passion. The dichotomy
exceeded simply convincing a jury but convincing a jury comprised of the
members of close knit and very unique community who were determining the fate
of an outsider. This enthralling film follows the courtroom proceedings that
follow the gruesome events that unfolded at the Big Bay Inn in Big Bay,
Michigan.
On
July 31, 1952, A Lieutenant in the US Army, Coleman Peterson shot and killed a
man, former Michigan State Police officer Mike Chenoweth for allegedly raping
and beating his wife, Charlotte Peterson. According to The News-Palladium,
Benton Harbor, Michigan “Peterson’s wife went to the tavern last night to
purchase beer to take back to the trailer camp, and Chenoweth offered to drive
her home. On the way, she said, Chenoweth assaulted and raped her. In tears,
she told her husband, who picked up his gun and went to the tavern. There he
fired several shots at Chenoweth , striking him in the stomach, chest and right
arm. There were a dozen a more patrons in the tavern at the time of the shooting,
which occurred about 12:30 a.m.” (News Palladium, 1952) By August 7 of the same
year the trial had begun and concluded with a verdict of not guilty for Lt.
Peterson on the grounds of temporary insanity a mere six days later. The events
that unfolded in the 25th District Court (Michigan Courts, 2022) in
Marquette County were the foundational groundwork for a story that was destined
turn to gold on the silver screen.
Anatomy
of A Murder and its depiction of the People of
Michigan v. Coleman Peterson trial sets itself apart from many other factually
based court room dramas due to the films deeply inherent roots in the truth of
the matter. The film does not open with the typical “based on a true story”
frame that have become a contemporary symbol of validity for most true crime
dramas. But the absence of this cinematic commonplace does not cause the story
to deviate too far from the truth. The movie was filmed in its entity in
Marquette County, where the real trial occurred. The film is based on a book by
the same name by an author named Robert Travers. However, a little research
will prove that Robert Travers was a pseudonym. (Tribune, 1970) The author’s
actual name was John Voelker. John Voelker was the defense attorney for The
People of Michigan v. Peterson in 1952. Voelker’s identity was not the only
name changed in his book. Every important person in the trial was given a new
name and the filmmakers followed suit. In the film LT. Peterson is referred to
as Lt. Manion, Charlotte Peterson is
portrayed as Laura Manion, Judge Charles O. Arch was portrayed as Judge Weaver and the prosecuting
attorney was given the name Claude Dancer. John Voelker is referred to as Paul
Biegler. Voelker wrote this book in a semi-fictional fashion in attempt to tell
the complicated story that envelopes this murder and consequential trial
without possibly implicating any of the people involved. He had to be
particularly careful with his depiction of this case because he had a seat on
the Michigan State Supreme Court at the time his book was published. In fact,
he was still on the Michigan State Supreme Court until the book had become a
solidified hit. “Now assured of an adequate income, Voelker resigned from the
Michigan Supreme Court in January 1960 to devote his time to fishing and
writing.” (NMU, 2008) As this article expands on the various layers of this
murder trial, it will begin to bring to light the realities of the crime that
inspired Anatomy of a Murder while also highlighting the discrepancies
that the film makers may have portrayed in the name of a dramatic effect. However,
sandwiched between the truth in recounting of this story and the Hollywood flare
that made it a hit, there is a very American lesson to be learned.
The details and evidence of the
murder were piling up in favor of the prosecution before the trial had even begun.
But the most adversarial force Voelker was up against was a battle with the
aforementioned tightly knit community that the deceased (Chenoweth) was a part
of for his entire life. Chenoweth was a true Yooper.
Yooper:
an endearing and self-proclaimed title that the residences of the UP wear with
a badge of honor. The Yoopers are a unique group of Americans belonging to a
portion of Michigan that is often forgotten by outsiders.
But this sense of exclusion from the outside
world has stretched over generations and given birth to an unparalleled sense
of community that is exclusive to the Upper Peninsula. They care for one
another in a manner that is dedicated and true because they have the resources
to do so. The population in the UP is still small to this day and was
significantly less in 1952. The upper Peninsula is a collection of various
small towns that thrive in different ways from either mining or exporting iron
ore or the logging industry. As if the arduous labor involved in mining and
logging were not enough, the winter months are hard, treacherous, and long in
the UP. There is a communal sense of
suffering among those that soldier through these blistering winters. Facing some of nature’s harshest elements can
really create cohesion that is unparalleled. This peculiar element of closely bound
community was very important in the real trial and the depictions in the film. Far
be it from anyone to associate them with the lower state of Michigan, they are
a community and culture all their own.
The
judge in this case was a lower statesman. He was called up to oversee the
proceedings because the original judge, Judge Maitland had “an illness” (NMU,
2008) He recognized that his presence might cause some uneasiness with a jury
and courtroom comprised largely of Yoopers. In the Judge’s opening statement he
addressed his reason for travelling from up state to be a preside over the case
and assured the all in attendance that his main objective was to find the truth
above all else. In the film, Judge Weaver adds an element of comedic relief in
his statement. “ One judge is quite like another. The only
differences may be in the state of their digestions or their proclivities for
sleeping on the bench. For myself, I can digest pig iron. And while I might
appear to doze occasionally, you will find that I am easily awakened,
particularly if shaken gently by a good lawyer with a nice point of law.” (Time-Life
Multimedia, 1959) Judge Arch was portrayed as honest and integral throughout
the film.
The defense had an out of town judge
with the appearance of being less biased in their favor. Next, they had to
ensure that the jury did not feel biased toward Lt. Peterson. After all, he was
basically a stranger that had been placed in their community by the Army and
were unfamiliar with his character. However, the Lieutenant’s service to his
country seemed to have an impact on his appearance at the trial. The defense
would not only mention LT. Peterson’s combat service in Korea, but the
Lieutenant appeared at trial in his dress service uniform every day. He never
appears in civilian attire in the film or over the period of the actual trial. The only photograph of the Lieutenant in
civilian attire was taken sometime shortly after his arrest.
Voelker was crafting an excellent defense built on his clients proud military service and an out of town judge that was willing to maintain order in a seemingly chaotic courtroom. The courtroom was depicted as having hysterical outbursts in the film. One of which was over the use of the word “panties” which in the film is responded with laughter from those in attendance. But an interview that was conducted in 2008 with one of the jurors on the case. Shows that this famous scene had a little bit of hyperbole added by the camera. “The colorful person was John Voelker.” NMU, 2008) Max Mueller recalls after being asked about the courtroom hysterics. He said he remembered the courtroom to be relatively calm except when Voelker and Dancer would argue.
However,
it does seem that Mrs. Peterson’s panties were in fact a piece of evidence.
Apart from her actual underwear being retrieved and used as evidence. The film
depicts behavior in the courtroom that would deemed as grossly inappropriate
according to today’s standards. In the line of questions regarding Mrs.
Peterson’s alleged rape, one question was in reference to what she was wearing
that night. These questions stood without objection partially because it was
the 1950’s and partially because Mrs. Peterson had a colorful reputation with
men and alcohol. Especially, when her husband was absent. According to the
Chicago Tribune “The reason that Lt. Peterson had shot Chenoweth that night was
because Mrs. Peterson, who had been drinking and partying all evening at the
tavern, came home with a black-eye. She told her husband that Mike Chenoweth
raped her. It was later established in the court records that Peterson had a
jealous streak. One night, outside the tavern, he struck his wife. Witnesses
testified he accused her of flirting with one of the men stationed with him at
the U.S. Anti-Aircraft Range near Big Bay.” (Chicago Tribune, 1970)
Voelker had a difficult situation on
his hands as the Peterson’s dirty laundry was being aired out in front of the
jury. Voelker and Lt. Peterson decided to plead that the murder was committed
under a state of temporary insanity. Lt. Peterson plead that he did not
remember the killing in any capacity.
The lieutenant recalled the events
of July 31, 1952, as such in the film:
Lt.
Manion: “My next coherent recollection is back in the trailer.
Paul
Biegler: "Can you illustrate for us, Lieutenant, what position the
deceased assumed when he turned around?"
The
Lieutenant's words came in breathless spurts,
Lt.
Manion: "As I say, he turned.. To the best of my recollection he turned to
his right...
his
left hand on the bar... I cannot recall seeing his right arm."
Paul
Biegler: “You say his left hand on the bar or arm and hand?"
Lt.
Manion: "His left forearm. He kind of leaned."
Paul
Biegler: "State whether or not you remember driving back to the
trailer."
Lt.
Manion: "No, sir; I don’t-"
Paul
Biegler: “What happened when you got back to the trailer?"
Lt.
Manion: "I guess I came to.” (Time-Life
Multimedia, 1959)
According
to the researchers at Northern Michigan University, the copy of Voelker’s testimony
from the character dialogue between Lt. Manion and Paul Biegler does resemble
his actual testimony given during the trial. “The lieutenant's testimony
closely follows that of the actual trial, although it is condensed in places.” (NMU,
2008)
Upon hearing everything the defense
and prosecution had prepared and delivered, the jury returned with a decision
of not guilty, on the reason of temporary insanity. That is not just the storybook
ending that Lt. Manion received in Anatomy of A Murder but the real
decision in The People of Michigan v. Coleman Peterson.
The
unfolding of events behind the camera were not that much different than the
reality that unfolded in the Marquette County courtroom. There were certainly
many elements of Anatomy of a Murder that were accentuated for dramatic
effect. But when it comes to watching courtroom deliberations, sometimes a
little dramatic effect is needed. Despite any exaggerations of the truth used
to create the film, the indisputable fact that a complete outsider murdered a
Yooper in the UP, in front of a crowd of Yooper witnesses, then tried by
Yoopers was ultimately found innocent is truly incredible. Despite overwhelming
evidence that was not in the favor of the defendant. A jury comprised of close
knit community members, people that were able to feel the ripple of the murder
in their everyday lives, decided in the favor of Lt. Peterson. Lest it be
forgotten that Voelker was also a Yooper, being born and raised in Ishpeming,
Michigan. All of those factors in conjunction with one another, and he was still
able to use all of his local charm and convince the jury that one of their own
was not only capable of raping Charlotte Peterson but had done so beyond the
shadow of a doubt. Therefore, deserving of his death at the hands of her
temporarily deranged husband. Voelker’s work as an attorney was as equally stupendous
as James Stewart’s on screen portrayal of him. Many things can be misconstrued
through the lens of a camera as its directors attempt to simulate real court
room proceedings, but what it cannot distort is the empirical need to hire an
outstanding attorney when trapped in the grips of the law.






